New superhero movies like Superman
Returns and X-Men:
The Last Stand remind me of my one time comic book addiction. As a
child, I liked to read superhero comics but they had simple stories of
saving the world. As I grew up the stories became less interesting and
I stopped reading them.
In
my senior year of college I had a friend who collected comic books and
convinced me to start reading them again as the stories have added
some sophistication to them. During my last summer before I went to
grad school I read through much
of his collection. In my first few years of graduate schools I
continued to reach comics voraciously and at one point I used a mail-order
service to get 25-30 comic books a month.
At some point I realized that I read the books not so much for
enjoyment but to finish before the next month's batch arrived. So I
went cold turkey, I stopped reading comics and never went
back.
However I had gotten my apartment mate hooked and he decided
to take over my subscription. Several years later, this would be
the mid-90's, the two of us were walking around and entered a comic
book store for old times sake. I saw a rack of new releases and we had
a conversation that went something like this.
Me: There's Batman, I thought he was paralyzed. AM: He got better. Me: I heard Superman was dead. AM: He got better too. Me: And the Flash? I remember when he died. AM: That's Kid Flash all grown up. Me: At least Wonder Woman hasn't changed. AM: Actually that's her mother.
The Chicago Tribune just ran an editorial
on Spiderman revealing his identity to the world. No worries,
in due time the world will forget.
Here, the Brazilian Portuguese pulisher, Abril, decided to not publish the "Genesis" storyarc, cause they thought the quality was low and wouldn't sell weel. Ok.
The problem was... WW died in "Genesis" and was replaced by her mother. And THEY DECIDED TO HIDE IT FROM THE READERS!
They continued publishing the stories like Hypollita was Diana and changed dialogues according to that. I don't even like to remember that. I was not buying DC comics anymore, btw...
1) YES, comic books are really bad at consistency and continuity.
2) However, Comic Graphic Novels, which are stand-alone pieces, can be quite good. Two I recommend: WATCHMEN which takes place NOT in the Marvel or DC universe so it doesn't have all of that baggage, and THE DARK KNIGHT RETURNS which is a gritty look at BATMAN (It had a sequel THE DARK KNIGH STRIKES AGAIN which DID have the usual continuity problems.)
3) Worst Revisionism in comics in my experience: when I was a kid The Green Goblin killed Spidermans girlfriend Gwen Stacy, and later was killed (by accident) while fighting spiderman. Later Gwen Comes BACK- but NO, she's a CLONE. And much later The Green Goblin Comes back (the original one). He never died! The reason this one strikes me is that (again, I was a kid) this seemed to be very important- bad guy kills your girlfriend and ends up dead. But no, just press the giant RESET button and all is back where it started.
4) The CIVIL LIBERTIES series (or whatever its called) in the Marvel Universe now MIGHT be interesting as a stand-alone piece, but Lance is right- Spiderman will go back to having a secret identidy at some point. Mass hypnosis? Time Travel? They'll find a way.